Essential reading for education companies worldwide
Remember me:
Skip Navigation LinksEI article
Exclusive: Providers ‘barely breaking even’ from £1bn Saudi college programme

A major programme to run colleges in Saudi Arabia said to be worth £1 billion to the UK economy has been dubbed a failure by several UK providers involved in the project, who say they are struggling to break even. 

Some 16 British operators have been hired to run 37 Saudi institutions under the Colleges of Excellence (COE) programme, which is designed to improve provision of vocational education in the Kingdom. 

However, representatives of several operators told EducationInvestor student demand had been minimal, and that some have been left running virtually empty colleges.

This has left some struggling to meet their costs – a situation exacerbated by “unrealistic” performance-related targets, staff shortages and poor infrastructure.

Highlighting the discord, Pearson, which was contracted to run three colleges through its TQ division in 2013, has confirmed it dropped out of the programme in June.

It is understood to be in a legal dispute with the Colleges of Excellence – the private company contracted to run the programme on behalf of the Saudi government – but declined to comment on the matter. The chief executive of COE, Dr Saleh Alamr, did not respond to email requesting comment. 

‘Colleges could go bankrupt’

Launched in 2012, the Colleges of Excellence scheme involves providers from several countries, including the US, New Zealand and Germany, but UK companies and colleges have won most contracts to date. 

Most are operating in consortia, such as Hertvec, which includes Hertford Regional College, North Hertfordshire College and Saudi construction firm Samama Holdings. It won a £225 million five-year deal to run three colleges in 2014.

Dr Ian Baird, who stepped down as chief executive in June, said after numerous challenges he did not expect the group to break even.

“The Colleges of Excellence project was deemed to be a massive change to how technical and vocational education is delivered in the Kingdom, but the initial excitement for providers has waned," said
Baird, who previously led Pearson's Saudi consortium. 

“The size and complexity of this project could actually cause British state-funded colleges to go bankrupt, as they incur costs without getting paid for the resources they are providing.”

‘Ghost colleges’

Others said they had also struggled – their chief complaint being they were told there would be high demand for their courses before signing up.

Promotional materials at the time stated “enrolment numbers are unlikely to be of concern”, and that "there is far greater demand for vocational training in the Kingdom than supply". But in reality take-up has been low, particularly at colleges in remote parts of the country.

One institute, run by German trade body GIZ and engineering firm Festo, is understood to have around 50 active students, despite having a capacity for several thousand. A UK consortium which preferred not to be named confirmed one of its colleges only has 60 students, while Hertvec’s numbers are understood to be well below target.  

One provider said: "You get paid on a per pupil basis and in some of our colleges there isn’t enough volume to support the core faculty staff.

“You’re also paid for attendance – if students attend 80% of their anticipated hours – but dropout rates have been very high, because respect for vocational education is low and many students don’t have the aptitude to progress."

He said the consortium “might break even” this year, because one of its urban colleges is well attended. But the group is unlikely ever to achieve its anticipated profits, he said.

“We have been given ‘minimum guarantees’, but to be honest they are pretty worthless because our operating cost base is far in excess of that.”

Chris Kirk, the former chief executive of GEMS Education Solutions, set up the The Oxford Partnership, comprising GEMS Education (since replaced by Al Farabi College), Activate Learning and Moulton College. 

It won a deal in 2014 to run four women’s colleges in Al Jouf Sakaka, Arar, Al Qurayyat and Al-Madinah.  

Kirk, who is now a partner at PwC, said "the vision [of the programme] remains a strong one" but conceded there had been challenges.

"[These include] recruiting and acclimatising the required numbers and quality of Western staff to life in Saudi Arabia, overly-optimistic initial projections of student demand, a lack of understanding of the length of study needed so that students will achieve English proficiency, and teething problems with the infrastructure provided." 

Embarrassment for UKTI

The Saudi government did not respond to email requesting comment, but in April the country’s Consultative Assembly halted the opening of new colleges until quality concerns were addressed. 

Others said they blame foreign contractors for not doing proper due diligence and underestimating the risks of operating in Saudi Arabia. 

The revelations will be an embarrassment for UK Trade & Industry (UKTI), the government agency tasked with promoting British education abroad. Last April it described the Colleges of Excellence programme as “a £1 billion exports win for UK education”, while former skills minister Matthew Hancock called it “a vote of confidence in the UK’s improving education system”.

UKTI declined to comment, but is understood to acknowledge the challenges and be working to find a solution.

It also comes at a bad time for English colleges which face mounting financial difficulties after five years of stringent cuts. Eight of the providers involved in COE are taxpayer-funded, and Baird said that public money was being wasted.

COE providers such as Highbury College, Activate Learning and Hertford Regional College declined to comment, while others did not respond to requests for comment. 

However, a principal who did not want to be named, told EducationInvestor his college was indeed making losses.

“I don’t believe anybody is going to make money out of the Colleges of Excellence programme. They will also find it very hard to extract themselves from the contracts which are frankly grisly.”


Posted on: 03/12/2015

Latest news

Shares in listed Chinese education firms tumbled in today’s trading after Beijing tightened its grip on the early years sector, banning private kindergartens from floating or raising funds from listed companies.
Catapult Learning, a US-based provider of special needs education, has acquired Capital Education Group, a provider of curriculums geared at students with autism, for an undisclosed price.
Prodigy Finance has launched a loan refinance product aimed at expat graduates living in the UK or US who are looking to reduce their student debt.
Wellspring International Education, a student recruitment firm, has acquired embattled pathway provider Quad Learning for what is reportedly a fraction of the venture capital it raised upon launching just six years ago.
Cornerstone OnDemand, a cloud-based learning and talent management solution provider, will acquire Grovo Learning, a provider of bite-sized employee training, for $24 million, expanding its suite of education products.
Northeastern University in Boston is set to buy The New College of the Humanities, a fledgling private university in central London, in a bid to globalise its operations.
Australian education group Navitas has rejected a takeover bid from BGH consortium, which includes the firm’s former chief executive and co-founder, as the offered price did not satisfy its strategic goals.
Pearson is to sell One Southwark Bridge, a property used by the Financial Times as its headquarters, to M&G Real Estate for £115 million.
Learning and Work Institute says it is searching for individuals, tutors, employers and projects that have shown a special commitment to lifelong learning.
An international group of academics is planning to launch a new journal that will publish articles under pseudonyms in response to a culture of fear and self-censorship on campus.

my images

Asia | China regulation

Tumultuous times lie ahead for school operators in China as regulators take aim at structures widely used by overseas investors to extract earnings from non-profit education businesses. What impact will the proposals have on industry incumbents, market entrants and their investors? Josh O'Neill investigates

Christie + Co

Europe | Vocational training

Employers stand to lose millions unless they start setting up more apprenticeships with the cash they have paid into the government's scheme, writes Josh O'Neill

Veale Wasbrough Vizards